Though his directing career dates back to 1962, it wasn't until the mid-1980s that Im Kwon-taek began to receive international recognition as one of Korea's true masters of cinema. Popular on the festival circuit, films such as Gilsoddeum (1986), The Surrogate Mother (1987), and his greatest achievement , Seopyeonje (1993) received critical praise (plus a few awards),
but rarely found their way to these shores. Im's breakthrough in the States would come in 2000 with the release of Chunhyang, followed by 2002's Chihwaseon – two very good films, but certainly not his best.Prior to Chunhyang, Im wrote and directed his 96th film, Chang (aka Downfall), a flawed but earnest melodrama from 1997 that tackles Korean history from the rise of industrialism in the 70s to the economic slump of the 90s, as viewed from the underworld of brothels and prostitutes.
The film begins during the great modernization period under the Park Chung Hee regime – a time, as we learn, when women were mostly forced, or coerced into prostitution. Such is the case with teenaged orphan Young-eun (Shin Eun-kyung), who mistakenly believes she is being hired simply to sell soda in exchange for room and board. Raped by the brothel owners, and threatened with physical violence if she runs, Young-eun is quickly transformed from an innocent teen full of terror and disgust to just another savvy, desensitized professional working the narrow, crowded street. The sudden shift is a bit disconcerting, though it's a far cry from the misogynistic fantasies dreamed up by Kim Ki-duk in films like Bad Guy or Samaria.
Like the "hostess films" that were popular in the 70s, Chang chronicles Young-eun's many vicissitudes, including several aborted attempts at marriage, and a brief stint as a brothel owner herself. It also follows her long-term friendship with Gil-young, a kind, selfless man she no doubt truly loves, but can never be with. If the film offered nothing more than this, it would be easy to dismiss it as just another formulaic melodrama, but fortunately Im brings much more to the proceedings.
Key events in Korea's history during the film's twenty years period – including the assassination of President Park, the military coup that led to the rise of President Chun Doo-hwan, and the 1988 Olympics – appear on cheap televisions located in the brothels. The women are indifferent to these events, and most don't even bother paying attention, yet not out of apathy. As societal outsiders their role is limited to generating capital with their bodies, and paying back a seemingly never-ending debt to the brother owners. Political and social changes are meaningless to them, unless of course it affects their trade (as the introduction of AIDS will, late in the film.) Economic swings, however, are mirrored in their industry – during the peak years we learn that the demand for prostitutes was at a record high, and that there were 400,000 brothels, and over one million women working in them.
It would be wrong to consider Chang progressive in its views. In fact in some ways it is downright regressive – in both it's method of storytelling, as well as its conceit of representing Korea's tumultuous history through the commodification of women. Its sexual explicitness is anything but erotic, and at times feels vaguely exploitative. Yet even with these flaws, Chang finds Im in top form as a director, and it is visually one of his most fascinating films.
Shot primarily in tight, cramped spaces, Chang is the aesthetic opposite of Seopyeonje, which emphasizes the vastness of the landscape, and often maintains a distance from its characters. Here Im often crowds his frame, placing characters simultaneously in fore- and background, and making great use of deep focus. (The film requires several viewings just to catch everything.) His compositions are nothing short of masterly (see above, bottom picture), and his framing is strangely reminiscent of Fassbinder's. The use of cutaway walls allows for epic tracking shots through the brothels, and the end result is chillingly powerful. The few scenes shot outside the city draw sharp distinctions in light – the almost blinding rays of the sun versus the dim, artificially colored glow of the brothels. Im also utilizes several visual motifs that are repeated throughout the film – an extremely nice touch.
Though closer in tone to his early genre films than to his masterpieces of the 80s and 90s, Chang is still worth seeking out for the visuals, as well as a remarkable lead performance by Shin Eun-kyung. A subtitled Korean-released DVD, which looks great, is available here. |